Purpose
Chamber κ₁ operates on τ-stable ensembles from Chamber κ₀, selecting states based on intrinsic symmetry measures. It does not modify τ-dynamics or generate new states—it purely selects among existing τ-stable outcomes.
Symmetry Measures
- Σ₁ (Mean Bias): |⟨x⟩| — translation symmetry breaking
- Σ₂ (Reflection): Σ|x[i] − x[N−1−i]| — spatial inversion asymmetry
- Σ₃ (Spectral Odd-Mode): Fraction of power in odd Fourier modes
- Σ₄ (Chirality): |Σ(x[i] − x[i+1])| — rotational orientation bias
Selection Policies
- Pure: argmin Σᵢ — select minimum of single measure
- Lexicographic: Σᵢ → Σⱼ → Σₖ — hierarchical tie-breaking
- Negative Control: argmax Σᵢ — anti-selection for comparison
κ₁ vs κ₁′ Modes
κ₁ (Standard Mode):
- Tests all 4 symmetry measures (Σ₁, Σ₂, Σ₃, Σ₄)
- Diagnostic — reveals which axes are discriminative
- May include null axes (zero variance, high degeneracy)
- Validation may show PARTIAL if some axes are non-discriminative
κ₁′ (Active-Only Mode):
- Auto-filters null symmetry axes before selection
- Uses only empirically active measures
- Improves determinism by removing degenerate dimensions
- Conditioned selection — adapts to ensemble structure
Workflow: Run κ₁ (standard) first to identify null axes → Inspect results → Run κ₁′ (active-only) to validate determinism improvement
κ₁′ Null-Axis Criteria
An axis Σᵢ is classified as null if any of:
- Zero variance: Var(Σᵢ) < 10⁻⁶
- High degeneracy: >50% of states share minimum value
- Vanishing gap: Gap to 2nd minimum < 10⁻³
Example: In your run, Σ₄ (chirality) showed Var ≈ 0, degeneracy = 100%, gap = 0 → classified as null
Validation Criteria
κ₁ Standard Criteria:
- Cκ1-1: At least 2 states differ in each Σᵢ
- Cκ1-2: ≥95% of policies resolve deterministically
- Cκ1-3: κ₁ does not alter U or W distributions
- Cκ1-4: Different policies select different states
- Cκ1-5: Report degeneracy metrics for all policies
κ₁′ Additional Criteria:
- Cκ1′-1: At least one Σᵢ classified as null and excluded
- Cκ1′-2: Determinism improves relative to κ₁ standard
- Cκ1′-3: Selections are subset of κ₁ selections (consistency)
Required κ₀ Data Format
{
"ensemble": [
{
"state_id": "s_0042",
"config": [x₀, x₁, ..., x₆₃], ← Required for full κ₁
"energy": 1.234,
"wall_count": 8,
"mean": 0.023
},
...
]
}
Agnostic Principle
κ₁ does not assume symmetric states are "better" or have lower energy. It empirically tests whether symmetry has discriminative power. Non-correlation with energy/topology is equally informative.