Voyager 1 MAG → DLCP Multi-Scale Robustness Results

Figure-ready HTML developed from STRUC-PERC-I batch outputs in the given multi-scale results archive. Window scales: W512/S128, W1024/S256, W2048/S512. Years: 2011–2017.

Result summary

t* = 2012 is stable across all three window scales. The annual mean κconn minimum occurs in 2012 for W512/S128, W1024/S256, and W2048/S512. This supports the claim that the Voyager 1 MAG structural boundary estimator is not an artifact of the baseline 1024-sample DLCP window.

Robustness3 / 3 scales

All scales identify 2012 as the κ minimum.

Coverage10,500 runs

7 years × 3 scales × 500 windows.

Main diagnosticκ minimum

Boundary estimator remains fixed under window-size variation.

1. Robustness table

The table below summarizes the boundary estimator at each scale. The post/crossing ratio is computed as mean κconn over 2013–2017 divided by the 2012 minimum.

scale tstar min_kappa post_mean jump_2012_2013 post_to_crossing_ratio exc_2011 exc_2012 exc_post_mean
W512_S128 2012 5,872.3224 13,984.3353 2.6280 2.3814 0.0360 0.0200 0.0152
W1024_S256 2012 14,685.6109 31,775.5210 2.1148 2.1637 0.0740 0.0520 0.0112
W2048_S512 2012 47,561.9957 78,113.4832 1.4587 1.6424 0.1200 0.1000 0.0084

2. Figures

Line chart of annual mean kappa across three window scales showing minimum in 2012 for all scales.
Figure 1. Annual mean κconn across window scales. Every scale reaches its minimum in 2012, confirming scale-stability of the structural boundary estimator.
Line chart of normalized kappa boundary coordinate across years and window scales.
Figure 2. Normalized boundary coordinate Bκ. The crossing year is normalized to zero at each scale; post-2012 values rise into a distinct post-crossing range.
Line chart of excursion density across years and window scales.
Figure 3. Excursion density across scales. The strongest boundary-adjacent enrichment occurs in 2011–2012 for the baseline and coarse windows. The fine window reduces amplitude but preserves the pre/crossing emphasis.
Line chart of FULL dominance percentage across years and window scales.
Figure 4. FULL dominance. All scales remain overwhelmingly FULL, while boundary information appears as localized deviations rather than global class collapse.
Line chart of mean tail dominance across years and window scales.
Figure 5. Mean tail dominance. Post-2012 tail dominance is elevated across all scales, supporting separation between heliosheath/crossing and ISM-side structural regimes.
Phase plane plot of annual mean kappa versus tail dominance labeled by year.
Figure 6. Phase plane, κconn vs tail dominance. The trajectory relocates from low-κ boundary-side coordinates into a higher-κ post-crossing region.
Bar chart showing minimum annual mean kappa for each scale, annotated t*=2012.
Figure 7. Window-scale robustness of t*. The κ minimum is 2012 for every tested DLCP scale.

3. Complete annual summary

Each row aggregates 500 STRUC-PERC-I batch outputs for one year and one window scale.

scale year windows mean_kappa median_kappa full giant tail hard exc_density full_pct mean_tailDom B_kappa
W512_S128 2011 500 6,303.2422 2,349.3555 482 8 8 2 0.0360 0.9640 0.7853 0.0531
W512_S128 2012 500 5,872.3224 2,113.5061 490 0 10 0 0.0200 0.9800 0.7713 0.0000
W512_S128 2013 500 15,432.2217 13,081.8604 492 2 6 0 0.0160 0.9840 0.9494 1.1785
W512_S128 2014 500 13,895.0917 11,487.3057 492 2 6 0 0.0160 0.9840 0.9417 0.9890
W512_S128 2015 500 12,438.9709 11,247.0268 492 0 8 0 0.0160 0.9840 0.9398 0.8095
W512_S128 2016 500 13,403.7220 9,431.0240 488 6 6 0 0.0240 0.9760 0.9323 0.9284
W512_S128 2017 500 14,751.6699 12,412.0779 498 0 2 0 0.0040 0.9960 0.9461 1.0946
W1024_S256 2011 500 18,186.9842 5,186.6817 463 26 10 1 0.0740 0.9260 0.7809 0.2049
W1024_S256 2012 500 14,685.6109 5,019.0908 474 16 10 0 0.0520 0.9480 0.7758 0.0000
W1024_S256 2013 500 31,056.6130 24,233.6773 500 0 0 0 0.0000 1.0000 0.9469 0.9579
W1024_S256 2014 500 28,747.7051 21,020.5233 495 4 1 0 0.0100 0.9900 0.9382 0.8228
W1024_S256 2015 500 27,282.2705 20,612.4959 489 5 6 0 0.0220 0.9780 0.9363 0.7371
W1024_S256 2016 500 35,805.5652 18,635.2213 488 10 2 0 0.0240 0.9760 0.9324 1.2358
W1024_S256 2017 500 35,985.4509 23,484.4689 500 0 0 0 0.0000 1.0000 0.9459 1.2463
W2048_S512 2011 500 49,503.7184 7,632.7189 440 48 12 0 0.1200 0.8800 0.7607 0.0636
W2048_S512 2012 500 47,561.9957 15,404.6969 450 46 4 0 0.1000 0.9000 0.8136 0.0000
W2048_S512 2013 500 69,379.5275 44,151.7813 498 2 0 0 0.0040 0.9960 0.9454 0.7141
W2048_S512 2014 500 81,291.7662 40,258.8520 499 1 0 0 0.0020 0.9980 0.9415 1.1040
W2048_S512 2015 500 73,038.2210 36,632.7601 496 4 0 0 0.0080 0.9920 0.9332 0.8339
W2048_S512 2016 500 84,474.7127 37,476.4042 488 12 0 0 0.0240 0.9760 0.9372 1.2082
W2048_S512 2017 500 82,383.1885 45,531.7980 498 2 0 0 0.0040 0.9960 0.9467 1.1398

4. Manuscript-ready conclusion

Across DLCP window scales W512/S128, W1024/S256, and W2048/S512, the annual mean κconn minimum remains fixed at 2012. The result is therefore stable under a fourfold change in window duration, from approximately 6.8 hours to 27.3 hours per window. The multi-scale test supports the interpretation of 2012 as a structural boundary estimator t* and weakens the objection that the heliopause signature is an artifact of the baseline 1024-sample window.

5. Caveat

The robustness result validates the annual-scale boundary estimator under the three tested DLCP scales. It does not by itself establish coordinate-invariant geometry, nor does it replace the need for additional physical-domain controls. It directly addresses the segmentation-artifact objection for Voyager 1 MAG.